18/11/2026
64% of Germans ask the seller for proof a used car is undamaged. Only 1.9% check it

Živilė Barkauskaitė

Only 1% of Germans who bought a used car in the past year took it to an independent mechanic before buying, and just 1.9% ordered a vehicle history report, reveals our recent study. The survey, conducted in August–September 2026, polled 261 residents of Germany who had bought a used car in the past 12 months. German buyers clearly want to know a car's past, but most of them simply take the seller's word for it.
That trust can be costly. Our new data shows that 43.6% of vehicles checked in Germany since the start of 2026 had damage records, and 2.2% had been severely damaged – with repair costs exceeding half of the car's value.
The right questions, asked of the wrong person
The study shows that German used car buyers are not indifferent to a vehicle's past. When asked what information they want from the seller, 41.4% of buyers named accident and damage history and 37.9% named service history, the carVertical study shows. And yet, the steps they actually took were simple: online research (78.2%) and viewing the car in person (36%). If the seller’s word is the only source of information about a specific vehicle, can you really trust it?
"German buyers ask the right questions. They want to know how the car was used, how it was maintained and whether it was ever repaired. The problem is who they ask, says Gabrielė Slabšienė, carVertical’s lead researcher behind the study, "A seller has every reason to present the car in the best possible light. A verbal answer or a selection of service invoices is not the same as independent proof."
Yet asking is where most buyers stop. 64% asked the seller for proof that the car had not been damaged, 30% never asked, and 6% wanted to ask but did not. For many, the seller’s word is the only check available. “At this point nothing, other than to trust what is shared,” one respondent said. “There is no way one can check the information that the car seller is telling.”
Don’t just take the seller’s word for it
Enter the VIN and see the car’s mileage, damage records and more before you buy.
Almost nobody checks independently
Despite this interest, very few buyers verify what they are told. Only 1% took the car to an independent mechanic before signing the deal, and only 1.9% ordered a vehicle history report.
Part of the explanation is simple awareness. Half of the Germans surveyed had never heard of vehicle history reports or did not know that such reports exist. In other words, buyers rely on the seller's account, and half of them do not even know that this account can be checked.
"Information about a car's mileage, past accidents, theft records and ownership changes is often recorded in registries, insurance and service databases. It exists – it just does not travel with the car," explains G. Slabšienė. "If buyers don't know this data is available, the seller's story is the only version they ever hear."
Dealers see the consequences of this every day. "Often there is no deliberate deception behind it, but rather incomplete information: damage is played down and only partly disclosed," says Michael Skule Langbehn, Member of the Executive Management at the German dealer group Süverkrüp.
In some cases, a customer was never informed about prior damage because it occurred with the previous owner and was not disclosed at the time of purchase. Trust is important, but it does not replace a professional inspection.
Michael Skule Langbehn, Member of the Executive Management at the German dealer group Süverkrüp.
What the seller may not mention
Since the start of 2026, 43.6% of vehicles checked by carVertical in Germany have had damage records, and 2.2% had been severely damaged – meaning the cost of repairs exceeded 50% of the vehicle's value. That is roughly 1 in every 45 cars checked.
Germany compares well with some of its neighbours. Its share of severely damaged cars is on par with Czechia and almost three times lower than in Poland.
According to the carVertical Transparency Index 2026, the average damage claim in Germany is €4,785, the 6th highest of the 23 countries studied. Odometer fraud is rarer but costly: 1.9% of vehicles checked had a rolled-back odometer, cut by an average of 54,440 km. This can inflate a car’s price by around 50%, a significant loss for the buyer.
"Germany's figures look better than in some neighbouring markets, but they are far from zero. More than four in ten cars checked this year had a damage record," says G. Slabšienė. "A car that was damaged and properly repaired can still be a good buy, as long as the buyer knows about it and pays a fair price. When that history stays hidden, the buyer pays for a car that is worth less than they think."
According to Skule Langbehn, undocumented accident damage and concealed repaint and bodywork repairs are the hidden defects dealers encounter most often, followed by odometer manipulation, flood and hail damage, poor-quality repairs and undisclosed use as a rental or commercial vehicle. "Many vehicles look flawless at first glance. Only a detailed inspection or history check reveals more significant prior damage," he says. "Depending on the damage, the difference in value can amount to several thousand euros."
The problem is growing. Skule Langbehn notes that letters from lawyers in the vehicle trade have increased significantly over the past 18 months, as customers complain about defects that surface after the purchase but were not communicated at the time of sale.
“At Süverkrüp, we recently introduced an additional step to increase transparency and buyer confidence. Every vehicle we purchase or take in as a trade-in is checked through carVertical as part of our acquisition process. This gives us greater certainty about the vehicle’s history from the very beginning and provides future buyers with an additional level of security. Greater transparency helps build trust and allows both dealers and customers to make informed decisions,”- suggests a solution S. Langbehn.
How to check a used car before you buy
Verifying a car takes far less time and money than dealing with hidden problems after the purchase. G. Slabšiėnė recommends the following steps:
1.Ask for the VIN before the viewing. A seller with nothing to hide will share it and hesitation is always a warning sign.
2.Check the vehicle's history. A vehicle history report shows recorded mileage, damage, equipment list and specification. Compare it with what the seller has told you.
3.Cross-check the service records. Make sure dates and mileage in the service book and invoices match the history report.
4.Book an independent inspection. Choose a mechanic you selected yourself, not one recommended by the seller.
5.Take a proper test drive. Drive at different speeds, try a bumpy road and listen for unusual noises and check that all systems work.
6.Be ready to walk away. If the seller refuses an inspection or the facts don't add up, look for another car.
"In the used car business, transparency is one of the most important factors for trust," says Skule Langbehn. "The better a vehicle's history is documented, the more confidently buyers and dealers can assess its actual value. This protects both sides from unpleasant surprises."
"Trusting the seller is not wrong. Trusting without checking is," G. Slabšienė concludes. "Buyers already ask the right questions – the next step is to verify the answers."
About the study
The survey was conducted by carVertical in August-September 2026 among 261 residents of Germany who had bought a used car in the previous 12 months. Damage data is based on vehicle history reports generated by carVertical in Germany, Czechia and Poland from 1 January 2026 to 20 October 2026. A vehicle is considered severely damaged when the estimated repair costs exceed 50% of its value.

Article by
Živilė Barkauskaitė
Živilė Barkauskaitė is a senior researcher and data journalist at carVertical. Since 2008, she has been writing professionally and researching how markets and consumer behaviour shift. At carVertical, she analyses vehicle history data to show what’s really happening in the used car market and to help drivers make safer, better-informed decisions.